Stop C-10: NO CRTC regulation of user speech

UPDATE: Bill C-10 is currently in front of the Senate, having cleared the House of Commons. With Parliament on summer recess since June 23rd, the Senate won’t continue its examination of C-10 until Parliament resumes in September. But should a federal election take place before then, Bill C-10 will “die”, meaning it loses its progress in the stages of becoming a law — but will likely be reintroduced from the beginning in the new session of Parliament.

The CRTC is about to be put in charge of every video, meme, and podcast we upload to the Internet.¹ Censoring videos with language that doesn’t fit the CRTC’s broadcasting standards? Limiting our timelines to display content from our Canadian friends? Imposing CanCon content requirements on app stores and video games? Taxing YouTube channels to fund traditional media?

All of that and more is now possible, after the government’s bait and switch removed safeguards that exempted user-generated content from Broadcast Act Amendment Bill C-10 at the very last minute.²

The government lied to us about this bill. Exempting our user content was a key part of C-10’s limitations, that helped get it through parliamentary readings and committee without more dissent. Removing that exception makes C-10 the most breathtaking power grab over online speech we’ve ever seen in Canada.

But there’s still time to stop this. Parliament has one final vote to decide if Bill C-10 becomes law. Tell your MP this kind of broad government censorship power is unacceptable – they MUST vote no to Bill C-10!

First Name

Last Name

Postal Code

Receive campaigns in English

Or...

Uncheck this box to unsubscribe from all updates.

Start writing your email to your MP!

*Note: Elements between brackets {} will be automatically filled-in with your MP’s information.*

We've included some text to help get you started. Feel free to edit the letter using the white text box below:

To: MP {contact_data~firstName} {contact_data~lastName}

As your constituent, I am writing to demand you vote no to Bill C-10, An Act to Amend the Broadcast Act, which was recently amended to include regulation of user-generated content on the Internet.

Supporting the production of Canadian cultural content is an important objective. But the current draft of Bill C-10 goes so much further than that, giving the CRTC full powers to impose broadcast-style regulations over every single piece of audio-visual content posted on the Internet by individual users. This means Internet platforms that host videos, memes, apps, and other content generated by individuals in Canada on the open web will be forced to uphold the same standards as radio and TV stations for every single post.

Minister Guilbeault has promised that the government will issue temporary guidance to the CRTC that limits the use of those powers in the short term. That’s not nearly good enough.

No matter how the current government may promise it will direct the CRTC to limit its use of these new powers – once they’re written in law, those extreme new powers are there to stay. Current and future governments could demand the CRTC crack down and limit how user content in Canada appears on the web as they see fit – without the checks and balances of public consultation or even a vote of parliament ever needed again.

The lesson of recent political upheavals in democracies is that our laws must be designed to resist future bad governance and potential abuses of power, not assume good intentions. It is completely unacceptable for either the Canadian government or the CRTC to be granted so much sweeping power to determine what people in Canada can watch and say online.

Please vote NO to Bill C-10. It needs to be sent back to the drawing board. Our government must re-imagine its goal of supporting Canadian culture to support innovative Canadian content native to new internet platforms, not impose inappropriate and suffocating 20th century regulation standards on the Internet.

Sincerely,

{user_data~First Name} {user_data~Last Name}

{user_data~Zip}

This campaign is hosted by OpenMedia. We will protect your privacy, and keep you informed about this campaign and others. Find OpenMedia's privacy policy here.

When Bill C-10 was announced, OpenMedia campaigned against it. Even in its original form, Bill C-10 was a dangerous failure. It threatened to drive major online platforms out of Canada, while doing nothing to reform our broken system for determining and supporting official Canadian content, or support the homegrown Canadian creators already flourishing on the social web.³

A lone bright spot of the bill was the specific exemption to regulation granted for user-generated content, highlighted in the government’s own press release, and characterized by the Department of Justice as a “carefully tailored” limitation to the Bill’s scope.^{4, 5}

In our worst nightmares, we never expected the government would break its own bill this badly, charging the CRTC with regulating every single one of the individual YouTube channels, TikToks and podcasts that we post and consume every day.

But that’s exactly what removing user-generated content exceptions from Bill C-10 accomplishes. No matter how the current government may promise it will direct the CRTC to limit its use of these new powers – once they’re written in law, those extreme new powers are there to stay. Current and future governments could easily demand the CRTC crack down and limit how user content in Canada appears on the web – without ever needing public approval or parliament to vote again.

That’s simply too much power to give to any government-appointed agency. If you haven’t already, tell your MP to vote NO on Bill C-10, and demand Broadcasting reform that is actually about supporting Canadian arts and culture – not censoring the Internet.

Sources

Uploads to social media could be regulated under proposed changes to Canada’s broadcasting law - Toronto Star
Freedom of Expression Under Attack: The Liberal Government Moves to Have the CRTC Regulate All User Generated Content - Michael Geist
What’s wrong with Bill C-10? An FAQ - OpenMedia
Supporting a Stronger, More Inclusive and More Competitive Broadcasting System - Newswire
Bill C-10: An Act to amend the Broadcasting Act and to make consequential amendments to other Acts - Department of Justice

If you haven't taken action yet click here

Press: Matthew Hatfield | Phone: +1 (888) 441-2640 ext. 1 | [email protected]